Written by Andrew Lenau | ISSA CPT & Sports Nutritionist
Fact checked by Kirsten Yovino, CPT Brookbush Institute
FACT CHECKED
When you're on a quest for a healthier and more active lifestyle, the first choice is selecting the perfect gym. Amidst the plethora of options, two heavyweight contenders emerge: Anytime Fitness and Planet Fitness.
These well-known fitness establishments often stand at the forefront of your decision-making process. The question remains: Which of these giants is the right match for you? In this comprehensive deep dive, we'll leave no treadmill untested and no free weight unracked as we explore the ins and outs of both gyms.
Whether you're a fitness enthusiast or just stepping into the world of health and wellness, this analysis will help you make an informed choice on the best gym for you.
Table of Contents:
- What Is Planet Fitness?
- What Is Anytime Fitness?
- Anytime Fitness vs Planet Fitness: Which Is Right For You?
- Anytime Fitness vs Planet Fitness: Cost Comparison, Virtual Tours, & Reddit Reviews
- Anytime vs Planet Fitness: Side-By-Side View
- FAQs
- Reader Question: Which Gym Do You Prefer?
What is Planet Fitness?
Planet Fitness has established itself as one of the largest gym chains in the United States, offering a no-frills, budget-friendly approach to fitness and the weight room. The gym's hallmark philosophy, the "Judgment Free Zone," is designed to create an easy-going atmosphere for novice and experienced gym-goers alike.
Planet Fitness Benefits:
What are the perks of Planet Fitness? Here are the top three benefits to this gym.
- Affordability: One of Planet Fitness's most noteworthy attributes is its low membership fees. This affordability ensures accessibility to a broad spectrum of individuals, regardless of their financial standing.
- Extensive Network: With over 2,000 locations in the United States, finding a Planet Fitness near your residence or workplace is relatively easy.
- 24/7 Access: One of the most celebrated features of Planet Fitness is its 24/7 availability, which empowers you to exercise at your convenience, be it in the early hours or well into the night.
Planet Fitness Cons:
No gym is perfect. Here are the Planet Fitness cons to consider.
- Limited Amenities: Planet Fitness caters to essential workout equipment but doesn't offer the vast amenities that higher-end gyms might. For those seeking luxury, it may fall short.
- Lunk Alarm: A unique feature at Planet Fitness is the "Lunk Alarm." While intended to maintain a non-intimidating atmosphere, some users focusing on muscle building find it discouraging, as it deters activities like grunting and loud workouts.
- Limited Personal Training Options: While Planet Fitness does provide personal trainers and personal training sessions, the scope and depth of these sessions may not be as comprehensive as those offered by specialized fitness centers.
What is Anytime Fitness?
Anytime Fitness is another leading gym franchise, and as its name suggests, it lives up to the promise of 24/7 access to its members. Renowned for its flexible hours and a strong sense of community, it's a sought-after choice for individuals with hectic schedules.
Anytime Fitness Benefits:
Here are the best Anytime Fitness benefits.
- 24/7 Access: Mirroring the convenience of Planet Fitness, Anytime Fitness offers the liberty of working out anytime, ensuring that your fitness regimen aligns with your unique daily agenda.
- Clean and Well-Maintained Facilities: Many users laud Anytime Fitness for the cleanliness and maintenance of their locations. Clean, well-kept facilities contribute to a positive gym experience.
- Varied Equipment: Anytime Fitness offers a more diverse selection of exercise machines and free weights, enabling a well-rounded workout.
Anytime Fitness Cons:
Before diving into an Anytime Fitness membership, consider these cons.
- Higher Membership Fees: Unlike Planet Fitness, Anytime Fitness memberships tend to be slightly pricier. This can be a consideration for budget-conscious individuals.
- Fewer Locations: While Anytime Fitness boasts approximately 4,000 locations worldwide, it may not be as easily accessible in certain regions compared to the extensive network of Planet Fitness. You may have a harder time finding a nearby Anytime Fitness location.
- Variable Atmosphere: The gym's atmosphere can differ from one location to another. While this could be seen as an advantage, as it caters to a diverse crowd, it can be a hit or miss for some users seeking a consistent ambiance.
Anytime Fitness vs Planet Fitness: Which Gym is Right for You?
When you're on the brink of deciding between Anytime Fitness and Planet Fitness for your fitness journey, it's essential to consider the factors that align with your specific needs and objectives. Here, we'll meticulously break down these elements to help you make an informed choice:
1) Contract Length:
One of the primary factors influencing your choice between Anytime Fitness and Planet Fitness is the contract length. Planet Fitness is known for offering no-commitment, month-to-month memberships, providing exceptional flexibility in your fitness commitment.
This feature is highly attractive to individuals who prefer maintaining control over their membership. In contrast, Anytime Fitness might have contract-based options.
It's crucial to verify the specific contract terms at your local Anytime Fitness branch before committing, as contract length can vary from one location to another.
2) Gym's Equipment:
The variety and quality of exercise equipment can significantly impact your workout experience. If you're searching for a gym with a broader selection of equipment, including an extensive free weights section and functional training equipment, you may prefer Anytime Fitness.
The diverse array of equipment at Anytime Fitness gyms can cater to both beginners and advanced fitness enthusiasts, offering a more comprehensive workout experience. Planet Fitness, while providing essential equipment, may not match the level of variety and options available at Anytime Fitness locations.
A third option for those not sold on commuting to a gym to get their workout in is to create a home gym. Check out these Best Home Gym Ideas for some serious inspiration!
3) Atmosphere:
The gym's atmosphere plays a pivotal role in ensuring that you feel comfortable and motivated during your workouts. If you prefer a non-intimidating, beginner-friendly environment, Planet Fitness's "Lunk Alarm" policy and its overarching "Judgment Free Zone" philosophy may be particularly appealing.
The atmosphere here encourages a more relaxed and welcoming environment, benefiting individuals new to the gym scene. Anytime Fitness, in contrast, offers a mixed atmosphere as it can vary from location to location.
To determine whether Anytime Fitness's ambiance aligns with your preferences, it's advisable to visit your local branch and gauge the atmosphere.
4) Gym Policies:
Anytime Fitness and Planet Fitness have policies that can influence your gym experience. These policies include dress codes, noise level restrictions, guest policies, and more.
To ensure that these policies align with your expectations and preferences, it's recommended to research them ahead of time. Familiarizing yourself with these policies will help you understand what to expect and avoid any potential surprises during your gym visits.
5) Group Fitness Classes:
If group fitness classes are a priority for you, it's crucial to inquire about the schedules and variety of group classes thateach gym offers. Whether you're interested in yoga, Zumba, spin classes, or other group workouts, the availability and frequency of these classes can significantly enhance your fitness journey.
Some individuals find motivation and camaraderie in group settings, making this a noteworthy factor to consider when choosing between Anytime Fitness and Planet Fitness.
6) Personal Training Sessions:
For those seeking guided workouts and personalized attention from a fitness professional, it's essential to review the availability and pricing of personal training options at both gyms. While some Planet Fitness do offer personal training, the scope and depth of these sessions may not be as comprehensive as what other specialized fitness centers provide.
Anytime Fitness may offer more extensive personal training options, but it's advisable to consult with your local branch to explore these opportunities further.
7) Amenities:
Gym amenities can significantly enhance your workout experience. Planet Fitness and Anytime Fitness offer various amenities, such as tanning, hydro massage, and locker room facilities.
Understanding which amenities are essential to you is a crucial step in selecting the right gym. Depending on your preferences and needs, one gym's basic amenities may align better with your fitness goals.
8) Locations:
The accessibility of your chosen gym is pivotal in ensuring consistency in your fitness routine. A convenient location can remove barriers to your commitment and motivate regular gym visits.
To determine which gym is more accessible, evaluate the availability of Anytime Fitness and Planet Fitness locations in your area. This proximity consideration can significantly impact your overall fitness experience.
By carefully weighing these factors and considering your fitness goals, you can choose between Anytime Fitness and Planet Fitness. The ideal gym for you will depend on your priorities, preferences, and what you value most in your fitness journey.
Interested in exploring other gyms before making a decision? Check out our comparison of LA Fitness vs Planet Fitness!
How Much is Anytime Fitness?
The cost of an Anytime Fitness membership can be influenced by several factors, with location and membership type being the primary determinants. Generally, you can expect the monthly fees to fall within the range of $30 to $50, but it's crucial to recognize that this range is subject to variation.
The exact cost of an Anytime Fitness membership may vary significantly based on where you reside and the specific membership plan you select.
In urban centers and high-demand areas, the cost may tend toward the higher end of the range.
Locations in smaller towns or less densely populated regions will likely offer more budget-friendly options. Furthermore, Anytime Fitness offers various membership types, such as single-club and multi-club memberships, each with its own pricing structure.
Multi-club memberships typically grant you access to a broader network of Anytime Fitness branches, which can be advantageous for those who travel frequently or want more flexibility in their workout locations.
How Much is Planet Fitness?
Planet Fitness has earned a reputation for offering budget-friendly membership options, making it an attractive choice for those looking to prioritize their fitness without breaking the bank. Many of their basic memberships start at an incredibly low price of approximately $10 per month.
At this affordable rate, you gain access to your local Planet Fitness branch, allowing you to take full advantage of their facilities, a wide array of exercise equipment, and fundamental amenities, all without a significant financial commitment. While the basic membership is a cost-effective entry point, Planet Fitness also provides a premium "Black Card" membership.
This Black Card membership, while slightly higher in monthly cost than the standard membership, offers additional benefits that can significantly enhance your fitness journey.
The Planet Fitness Black Card membership typically comes at a monthly cost slightly above the basic membership fee. The added investment, however, grants you an array of valuable perks, including:
- Access to All Planet Fitness Locations: With the Black Card membership, you're not limited to one specific branch; you can work out at any Planet Fitness location across the country. This is especially advantageous for frequent travelers or individuals who prefer the flexibility of choosing from various branches.
- Guest Privileges: The Black Card membership permits you to bring a guest with you to the gym on each visit. This is an excellent option if you enjoy working out with a friend or family member, as it allows you to share your fitness journey with others.
- Enhanced Amenities: Besides the standard amenities available to all members, Black Card holders enjoy access to exclusive amenities like hydro massage, tanning, and massage chairs. These additional comforts can elevate your gym experience and provide relaxation after your workout.
Anytime vs Planet Fitness: Virtual Tours
What better way to visualize what a gym is like than to actually see it? Enjoy the virtual tours below!
Anytime Fitness Virtual Tour
Anytime Fitness Clubs, a well-known fitness chain focusing on accessibility and convenience, understands the importance of transparency in attracting potential members. To this end, they offer a virtual tour that provides an immersive online experience.
Here's what it's like to step into your local Anytime Fitness.
Planet Fitness Virtual Tour
Planet Fitness, renowned for its commitment to making fitness accessible and welcoming, extends this approach to its online presence. The Planet Fitness virtual tour allows you to explore the gym's premises without leaving your computer.
Anytime vs Planet Fitness: Reddit Reviews
When making a decision as significant as choosing the right gym, there's no substitute for hearing from those who have already taken the plunge. Actual customer reviews offer insights into the day-to-day experiences, the pros, and the occasional cons of Anytime Fitness and Planet Fitness.
Let's delve into what actual users have to say about these gyms:
Anytime Fitness Reddit Reviews: What Do Real Gym Goers Say?
Anytime Fitness also gets relatively good reviews with one of the main perks being that at least some of the locations have private bathrooms.
One Redditor comments: "I've been to many different locations. Staff either pay no attention to you or are nice and friendly. More often than not there is not even staff there during staffed hours. Many times I get gyms all to myself. Some locations are packed, but that's rare. There are suggestions on bathroom time limits. In reality, there's no enforcement. So you can usually take your time. Highly recommend this gym." (source)
Another user compared Planet Fitness to Anytime Fitness, preferring Planet Fitness overall, but mentioning that Anytime Fitness' 24/7 hours was a big perk: "I have planet fitness and anytime fitness. I just got fed up with planet fitness closing on holidays and early on weekends. Planet fitness is the better gym. Anytime isn't that great. Old equipment and yes, the bathrooms are private but really gross because it's not staffed 24/7.
Twice I had to pick up a bar of soap off the shower floor and I saw a travel size toothbrush lay on the floor for a few days which tells me the bathrooms aren't being cleaned daily. The only thing good about anytime fitness is that it's open 24/7. It feels weird going in there late at night and there's only one person in there." (source)
Another Redditor on a separate thread states: "Anytime Fitness is a pretty solid place to work out at. I got a trial membership when I went home over winter break, the gym was never crowded. They had a power rack, dumbbells up to 100, and a pretty nice cardio setup. The best part is that it's truly 24 hours since they give you a keyfob that lets you tap in whenever, even when the gym isn't staffed. Definitely had some fun with 3 AM workouts when I couldn't get to bed." (source)
Planet Fitness Reddit Reviews: What Do Real Gym Goers Say?
The best way to learn more about a gym is to hear what real gym goers' experiences have been like.
For many who attend Planet Fitness, the overall experience has been great. One Reddit user stated: "It gets a lot of hate, but I really don't mind it. It's always clean, it's very rarely crowded when I go, and there's a ton of equipment. Not to mention, it's cheap as hell. If you're a beginner who just wants to lose some weight or tone up, it's FINE. If you're trying to be a body builder, a local gym with the heavy duty equipment may be better for you." (source)
Another Redditor added: "I enjoy it. All the staff I've ever met is super helpful, I think it's great for the price, the black card benefits are amazing, and they have a wide variety of equipment. Some people say it's hard to cancel, but I've never had issues." (source)
With another commenter in the same thread adding, ""I agree with a lot of what's already been said; also, the "judgement-free" part is big with me. I'm an older - well, bordering on "elderly" woman who just wanted to get more active, lose some weight and tone up. No one has ever given me grief or even a sidelong glance, like at other gyms." (source)
However, it's important to note that advanced trainees may struggle with the equipment selection, as one commenter points out: "It's pretty decent for the price, that is if you're a beginner or not interested in hardcore strength training. Weights don't go up to strong man levels. Generally if i need a machine that pf doesn't have i can use another machine or do the same kind of exercise with weights." (source)
Who is Anytime Fitness For?
Anytime Fitness caters to a broad spectrum of individuals, making it a versatile option for many fitness enthusiasts. Here's a breakdown of who Anytime Fitness is ideally suited for:
- Busy Professionals: Anytime Fitness's 24/7 access is a boon for those with hectic schedules. Whether you're an early riser or prefer late-night workouts, this gym accommodates your time constraints, making it perfect for professionals with demanding jobs.
- Frequent Travelers: Anytime Fitness offers global access to its members, allowing you to work out at any of its branches worldwide. If you're often on the go, this feature ensures you can maintain your fitness routine no matter where you are.
- Fitness Beginners: Anytime Fitness's welcoming and non-intimidating environment is ideal for those new to fitness. The lack of judgment and the supportive atmosphere make it a comfortable place to start your fitness journey.
- Fitness Enthusiasts: For those passionate about their fitness goals, Anytime Fitness provides a wide variety of equipment, including free weights and cardio machines, offering a well-rounded workout experience. You can also enjoy group classes and small group training sessions with fellow trainees.
- Individuals Seeking Convenience: The combination of 24/7 access, compact size, and modern facilities caters to individuals prioritizing convenience and accessibility in their fitness routines.
Who is Planet Fitness For?
Planet Fitness is known for its unique approach to fitness, characterized by affordability and a judgment-free atmosphere. Here's who Planet Fitness is ideally suited for:
- Budget-Conscious Individuals: Planet Fitness is renowned for its budget-friendly pricing, with memberships starting at an exceptionally low cost. It's perfect for those looking for a no-frills, cost-effective gym option. If you're looking to save money on gym memberships in the long run, also check out our article: How Much Does A Home Gym Cost? You may be surprised how budget-friendly it is in the long run!
- Fitness Beginners: The "Judgment Free Zone" philosophy of Planet Fitness creates a welcoming and non-intimidating environment, making it an excellent choice for individuals new to the gym scene.
- Casual Gym-Goers: If you're looking for a place to maintain a regular fitness routine without needing extensive amenities or advanced equipment, Planet Fitness offers a simple and effective workout environment.
- Individuals Who Value Convenience: With many (but not all) locations open 24/7, Planet Fitness provides accessibility and flexibility for those who want to work out on their schedule.
- Basic Fitness Needs: If your fitness goals primarily involve cardio equipment and basic strength training, Planet Fitness provides essential exercise equipment for a straightforward workout experience.
Interested in seeing how PF stacks up to another popular gym? Check out our article comparing Crunch vs Planet Fitness!
Anytime vs Planet Fitness: Comparing Side By Side
Here's a side-by-side view of these two popular gyms.
|
Aspect |
Anytime Fitness |
Planet Fitness |
|
Cost |
Monthly fees range from $30 to $50 |
Monthly fees start at $10 |
|
24/7 Access |
24/7 access |
Some are 24/7 |
|
Equipment |
Diverse selection of exercise machines & free weights |
Essential exercise equipment |
|
Atmosphere |
Typically welcoming and supportive |
Emphasizes "Judgment Free Zone” |
|
Policies |
Policies may vary by location |
Enforces policies to maintain non-intimidating atmosphere |
|
Classes |
Vary by location |
Range of group fitness classes |
|
Personal Training |
Offers PT options |
Provides training sessions |
|
Amenities |
Provides basic amenities |
Black Card membership: |
|
Locations |
Global access to its members |
Over 2,000 locations in US |
FAQs
Lingering questions regarding Anytime Fitness vs Planet Fitness? Let's answer them here!
How Much is a Gym Membership?
The cost of a gym membership can vary significantly depending on several factors, including the gym chain, your location, and the type of membership you select. Monthly fees for gyms like Anytime Fitness can range from $30 to $50, while Planet Fitness is known for offering budget-friendly memberships starting at approximately $10 per month. To get precise pricing details, contact your local gym or visit their website to explore available membership options.
How to get a Gym Membership?
Obtaining a gym membership is typically a straightforward process. You can sign up for a gym membership through the gym's official website, at the gym's physical location, or by calling customer service. Many gyms offer online registration and payment options, making joining convenient. The specific steps and requirements may vary by gym, so check with your chosen gym for detailed information on how to get started.
Does an Anytime Fitness membership work at all locations?
Anytime Fitness is known for its global access, which typically allows members to use any of their branches worldwide. This feature provides exceptional flexibility for those who travel frequently or desire the convenience of working out at various locations. However, it's advisable to verify this feature with your local Anytime Fitness branch to ensure it aligns with your needs and membership type.
Is the Black Card at Planet Fitness Worth It?
The Planet Fitness Black Card membership offers additional benefits, including access to all Planet Fitness locations, guest privileges, and enhanced amenities like hydro massage and tanning. Whether the Black Card is worth it depends on your needs and preferences. If you anticipate frequently working out with guests or wanting access to multiple branches, the Black Card membership can provide excellent value.
Planet Fitness images courtesy of Planet Fitness Instagram
Planet vs Anytime Fitness: Final Verdict
In the quest for the perfect gym, your decision between which commercial gym is best for you largely hinges on your unique priorities and preferences. If you value flexibility, accessibility, and a well-rounded array of equipment, Anytime Fitness could be your fitness sanctuary.
Its 24/7 access and diverse exercise offerings cater to a wide range of fitness enthusiasts, making it an ideal choice for beginners and seasoned gym-goers. On the other hand, if budget-friendly fitness and a non-intimidating environment are at the top of your list, Planet Fitness may be your gym of choice.
Its low-cost memberships and "Judgment Free Zone" policy create a welcoming atmosphere for those who want to embark on their fitness journey without the pressure of a high-end gym. In the end, both gyms offer compelling options. Consider your fitness goals, budget, and which features matter most to you.
Readers: Do you go to one of these gyms? Which do you prefer, and why? (Leave us a comment below!)
Interested in comparing these two gyms to another more expensive option? Check out our Life Time Fitness Review, which digs into the luxury gym's pros, cons, price points, and Reddit opinions. Or, for a more budget-friendly option, take a look at our Crunch Fitness Membership Review.
Anytime Fitness images courtesy of Anytime Fitness Instagram
Andrew Lenau
Author