Written by Andrew Lenau | ISSA CPT & Sports Nutritionist
Fact checked by Kirsten Yovino, CPT Brookbush Institute
FACT CHECKED
In the fitness world, choosing the right gym is a crucial decision that can significantly impact your health and well-being. Two popular choices that cater to different needs and preferences are Crunch and Planet Fitness.
In this comprehensive exploration of Crunch and Planet Fitness, we'll delve into various aspects, from the atmosphere to virtual tours, cost comparisons, and genuine user reviews. By the end, you'll have all the tools to decide which gym aligns best with your fitness goals and lifestyle.
Table of Contents:
- What Is Crunch Fitness?
- What Is Planet Fitness?
- Crunch Fitness vs Planet Fitness: Cost Comparisons, Virtual Tours, & Redditor Opinions
- Comparing Gyms Side By Side
- Which Is Best For You?
- FAQs
What is Crunch Fitness?
In the realm of fitness, Crunch stands out as a dynamic and rapidly expanding chain of fitness centers committed to redefining the workout landscape. This fitness haven caters to a diverse community of fitness enthusiasts, offering a rich tapestry of exercise options that span from traditional gym equipment to cutting-edge classes such as High-Intensity Interval Training (HIIT) and dance-based workouts.
Founded in 1989, Crunch Fitness has stood the test of time and is unwavering in its commitment to fostering a no-judgment zone. Whether you are a seasoned fitness veteran or taking your first steps into the world of exercise, Crunch embraces individuals of all experience levels and training preferences.
Crunch Fitness welcomes and encourages everyone on their unique fitness journey. Crunch Fitness distinguishes itself through its diverse club offerings, comprising franchise, signature, and select clubs.
The franchise clubs, the standard in Crunch's lineup, typically feature essential workout equipment, group classes, and a select set of amenities like smoothie bars or massage chairs. On the other hand, the signature and select clubs elevate the experience by including additional facilities such as pools, basketball courts, towel services, and an expanded repertoire of classes.
With a presence exceeding 300 locations across the US, Canada, and Australia, Crunch Fitness has become a fitness beacon accessible to a wide demographic. What makes Crunch particularly appealing is its commitment to affordability, with membership plans that align with various budget constraints.
This inclusivity in pricing ensures that Crunch Fitness remains an attractive choice for anyone seeking a fitness community that values diversity, innovation, and accessibility.
To learn more about Crunch, check out our comprehensive Crunch Fitness Membership Review!
What is Planet Fitness?
Planet Fitness, renowned as the "Judgment-Free Zone," is a unique fitness option. This gym chain has distinguished itself by championing inclusivity and affordability, carving out a space that welcomes individuals across the spectrum of fitness levels.
The "Judgment-Free Zone" isn't a mere marketing catchphrase for Planet Fitness; it's a guiding principle embedded in the gym's culture. Stepping into their facilities immediately imparts a distinct feel to the atmosphere.
Purposefully crafted to be non-intimidating and supportive, it holds a special allure for beginners or those who may have previously felt uneasy in more traditional gym environments. Beyond its branding, the iconic purple and yellow color scheme represents Planet Fitness's unwavering commitment to creating a judgment-free environment.
It's a tangible expression of the gym's mission to foster inclusivity and embrace individuals from all walks of life. Planet Fitness recognizes the considerable hurdle that intimidation poses for many contemplating a gym membership.
In response, they've meticulously cultivated an atmosphere where everyone feels accommodated and genuinely embraced regardless of their fitness experience. The goal is to dismantle barriers and provide a space where individuals can comfortably embark on their fitness journeys.
Adding to its appeal, Planet Fitness offers cost-effective membership options, extending accessibility to a wide demographic, including those with budget constraints. Whether taking the first step on your fitness journey or searching for a budget-friendly and supportive fitness community, Planet Fitness encapsulates the essence of fitness for all, exemplifying a philosophy that transcends mere workout routines to cultivate a holistic and inclusive approach to well-being.
Crunch Fitness vs Planet Fitness: What Are The Biggest Differences?
Crunch Fitness and Planet Fitness, both prominent names in the fitness industry, have distinctive features that cater to diverse preferences and fitness goals. Understanding the critical differences between Crunch Fitness and Planet Fitness can help you make an informed decision based on your needs.
Let's delve into some of the most significant contrasts between these two fitness giants.
Atmosphere and Philosophy
What can you expect when you walk into either gym? Here's a look at the atmosphere and philosophy of each.
1) Crunch Fitness:
At the heart of Crunch's ethos lies an energetic and motivating atmosphere that resonates with fitness enthusiasts seeking an active and dynamic community. The gym's emphasis on inclusivity transcends traditional fitness boundaries, inspiring individuals of all fitness levels.
From traditional gym equipment to innovative classes like High-Intensity Interval Training (HIIT) and dance-based workouts, Crunch aims to cater to diverse preferences, creating an environment that thrives on variety and intensity.
2) Planet Fitness:
Branded as the "Judgment-Free Zone," Planet Fitness takes pride in fostering a non-intimidating and supportive atmosphere. Geared towards beginners and those new to fitness, Planet Fitness is an inviting space prioritizing affordability and relaxation.
With a straightforward approach to cardio and strength equipment, the gym offers a comfortable entry point for casual gym-goers, emphasizing a judgment-free ethos.
Workout Options and Classes
If classes are your favorite part of the gym, Crunch Fitness may be the better option for you. Here's a look at what each gym offers.
1) Crunch Fitness:
Crunch Fitness stands out for its diverse workout options, embracing traditional gym equipment alongside innovative classes. High-intensity interval Training (HIIT) and dance-based workouts cater to fitness enthusiasts seeking variety and intensity in their exercise routines.
Crunch's commitment to providing a dynamic range of classes elevates the workout experience beyond conventional expectations.
2) Planet Fitness:
Planet Fitness takes a more straightforward approach, offering a range of cardio and strength equipment. While basic group fitness classes are available, the emphasis is on creating a comfortable environment for beginners and casual gym-goers.
The focus is on providing accessibility and a relaxed setting, making it an ideal starting point for those new to fitness.
Club Amenities
Each gym offers a variety of perks. Here's what you can expect with each.
1) Crunch Fitness:
Crunch distinguishes itself through a tiered club structure featuring franchise, signature, and select clubs. The latter two often include amenities like pools, basketball courts, towel services, and an expanded selection of classes.
This tiered approach caters to diverse preferences and expectations in terms of facilities.
2) Planet Fitness:
Planet Fitness maintains a consistent set of amenities across its locations, offering cardio machines and strength equipment, basic classes, and unique perks like "Pizza Mondays" and "Bagel Tuesdays" for Black Card members.
The uniformity in amenities contributes to a standardized experience across Planet Fitness locations.
Target Audience
Are you team Crunch or Planet Fitness? This will help you decide.
1) Crunch Fitness:
This appeals to a broad demographic, capturing the interest of fitness enthusiasts who thrive in a motivating environment and appreciate diverse workout options. Crunch accommodates those seeking a dynamic and engaging fitness community.
2) Planet Fitness:
Primarily targets beginners and casual gym-goers, positioning itself as an affordable and judgment-free space. It resonates with individuals who may feel intimidated in traditional gym settings, offering a more laid-back introduction to fitness.
Equipment may be a bit more limited here, so be sure to head into your gym sessions with good dumbbell exercises in mind. Check out our Best Full Body Dumbbell Exercises & Workouts so you go prepared!
How Much is Planet Fitness?
You'll be pleasantly surprised at how budget friendly Planet Fitness is, regardless of which option you pick. If you're looking for as many benefits as possible, the Black Card membership is likely the better option for you.
1) Basic Membership:
- Cost: Typically priced around $10 per month.
- Access: This membership tier provides entry to the gym facilities, allowing members to utilize the standard workout equipment and participate in basic fitness classes.
- Limitations: While cost-effective, the basic planet fitness membership may have limitations on additional perks, offering a straightforward and budget-friendly option for those primarily focused on standard workouts.
2) Black Card Membership:
You'll get the benefits mentioned above, plus a few more perks.
- Cost: Priced around $22.99 per month.
- Access: You'll get access to all Planet Fitness locations, providing flexibility and convenience for members who travel or prefer different gym settings.
- Extra Benefits: Guest privileges allow members to bring a friend for their workout sessions, and the utilization of amenities like massage chairs further enhances the overall gym experience.
The Black Card Membership offers an elevated fitness experience with added conveniences, making it suitable for those seeking a more comprehensive and versatile membership.
How Much is Crunch?
Similar to Planet Fitness, membership prices, even in the more expensive tier, are ultra budget friendly.
Basic Membership:
- Cost: Generally starts at $9.95 per month.
- Access: This tier provides access to the gym's facilities, allowing Crunch Fitness members to engage in standard workouts and utilize basic amenities.
- Scope: The basic membership caters to individuals seeking an affordable entry point to the gym environment, making it accessible to a wide range of budget constraints.
Peak Results Membership:
- Cost: Priced around $21.95 per month.
- Access: You'll get access to all Crunch Fitness locations, offering flexibility in choosing workout venues.
- Extra Benefits: Guest privileges enable members to bring friends along for shared fitness experiences. Premium amenities may include exclusive features not available with the basic membership.
The Peak Results Membership is tailored for those who desire an enhanced fitness experience, with additional perks and premium amenities designed to elevate their workout routine.
I'd recommend checking with the specific Planet Fitness or Crunch Fitness location you are interested in or visiting their official websites for the most accurate and current membership pricing details. Additionally, promotions or special offers may be available, so it's a good idea to inquire about ongoing deals when considering a gym membership.
A third option worth considering is investing in a home gym up front and avoiding gym membership costs all together! To learn more about this approach, check out our article: How Much Does A Home Gym Cost?
Crunch Gym vs Planet Fitness: Virtual Tours
What better way to visualize what a gym is like than actually to see it? Enjoy the virtual tours below!
Planet Fitness Virtual Tour:
Planet Fitness offers virtual tours through its official website and social media channels. These tours showcase their gym spaces, unique "Judgment-Free Zone" atmosphere, cardio and strength training areas, and additional amenities like tanning beds and massage chairs.
Be sure to visit the Planet Fitness website and YouTube channel for an immersive look at what you can expect when you enter one of their welcoming gyms.
Exploring these virtual tours will provide valuable insights into Planet Fitness's various fitness facilities, equipment, and overall vibe, helping you make a more informed decision based on your fitness goals and preferences.
Crunch Virtual Tour:
Crunch Fitness offers an immersive virtual tour experience, allowing you to explore their fitness facilities from the comfort of your own space. Accessing the Crunch Fitness official website or designated social media channels allows you to embark on a virtual journey through their gym spaces, capturing the energetic and motivating atmosphere that defines Crunch.
Check out this virtual tour of Crunch Fitness' Memphis Tennessee facility to get a sense of what the gym is all about!
This virtual exploration is designed to provide a firsthand look at the diverse equipment, vibrant ambiance, and overall layout of Crunch Fitness, empowering you to visualize what the gym offers.
Reddit Opinions: What Do Gym Goers Think?
When deciding as significant as choosing the right gym, there's no substitute for hearing from those who have already taken the plunge. Actual user reviews offer insights into the day-to-day experiences, the pros, and the occasional cons of Planet Fitness and Crunch.
Let's delve into what actual users have to say about these gyms.
Planet Fitness Reviews: Real Life Experience From Reddit Users
One of the big things on many lifter's minds is how the equipment is at a gym. One thing that pops up with Redditor's is that there are not barbells at many Planet Fitness locations.
One Redditor states: "I have a power rack at home and I workout at PF during the winter more because garage is too cold. I can still get a good workout at PF but I have to make adjustments. You can definitely get to intermediate level there. It’s not a powerlifting gym but it’s goofy to say you can’t make gains there if you are a beginner to intermediate. The only thing I don’t do there is deadlift. I might do RDLs with two dumbbells. You just adjust to what you have. I still front squat with two dumbbells. I just add more reps and I do lunges." (source)
Another user adds:
"They have dumbbells but not oly bar type barbells, just the preloaded short ones that go up to 65 lbs. if you like things like squats, deadlifts and bench press it’s difficult to really get a heavy weightlifter workout at PF. I see people using the smith machines for those exercises, but as a someone who used to power lift, I’m not a big fan of machines that force you into an unnatural position. You can still get a decent workout and there are plenty of alternative exercises but if you’re a fan of the big three it’s probably not the gym for you." (source)
For additional perspective on Planet Fitness and real-user experience, read the section below, summarizing a Reddit thread discussing how users feel about Planet Fitness.
Original Redditor's Story:
- Just got a job and can afford a gym membership.
- Considering local wellness center but finds it a bit expensive and inconvenient due to odd hours.
- Planet Fitness is a more affordable option with convenient hours, but concerned about horror stories related to the chain.
- Interested in starting with simple workouts like walking on a treadmill.
- Redditor Question: Do you all like Planet Fitness?
Key Redditor Comments on Planet Fitness:
Each of these bullet points represents a summary of a Redditor's opinion of Planet Fitness, along with some helpful pointers and thoughts on who PF is best for.
- Been at PF for 3 years and thinks it's great, clean, and organized; limitations on weights (dumbbells up to 65 lbs).
- One user suggests using a virtual credit card for PF membership and easily canceling by locking the card.
- Enjoys PF, praises cleanliness, and lists available equipment; highlights differences in PF locations; suggests checking the specific one.
- Worked at PF and provides insights on membership commitments and cancellation process; mentions 24/7 availability, free trainer, classes, and customizable workout programs.
- Advises that PF experiences vary by location, warns of mismanaged and dirty ones.
- Shares positive experience with easy cancellation process.
- Recommends PF for walking or running on a treadmill, emphasizing convenience.
- Didn't like PF due to crowding and perceived lack of free weights.
- Highlights PF horror stories about difficulty canceling and suggests using a reloadable Visa.
- Easily canceled PF membership by explaining unemployment.
- Recommends PF for beginners, positive interactions, attentive staff, and accessible cost.
- Advocates for PF depending on lifting goals, highlights absence of Olympic barbells.
- Highlights limitations of PF for weightlifting, lack of variety in equipment, and additional fees. (source)
Crunch Reviews: Real Life Experience From Reddit Users
The big question on our minds is what Crunch gym goers think about the equipment.
One Redditor provides some insight: "I go to Crunch. I only pay 15 a month, and it's a large facility. I'm surprised at all the different types of equipment they have. There are a lot of free weights. Many barbells, dumbbells, kettlebells, medicine balls, a few benches, squat racks, smith machines. Theres lots of other stuff like battle ropes, sleds, yoga balls, those balance ball things, ab wheels, jump ropes, heavy bags. Ellipticals, treadmills, and a lot of strength machines too. My location even has like a big jungle gym with pull up bars, monkey bars, pull up ladders, rock climbing rocks. It's definitely no Planet Fitness. There are some serious lifters at my gym." (source)
Another user adds: "The Crunch i've been to had 3 separate squat/oly racks, as well as a multi-purpose area that you can set pinions on to squat, dips, pullups, bands, etc. One of the best equipped commercial gyms I've ever seen. Only $20 a month as well as I can remember. My location also allowed chalk." (source)
Overall, Crunch appears to have a larger equipment selection than Planet Fitness, which is something to consider if a variety of equipment is important to your lifting needs.
For some more real user thoughts on Crunch Fitness, read the section below, summarizing a Reddit thread discussing how users feel about the gym.
Original Redditor's Story:
- Inquires about Crunch Fitness gym equipment, atmosphere, and contract terms.
- Concerns about the availability of squat racks and the "No judgements" policy.
- Redditor Question: Crunch Fitness - any thoughts?
Key Redditor Comments on Crunch Fitness:
Each of these bullet points represents a summary of a Redditor's opinion of Crunch Fitness and their thoughts on the gym.
- Describes positive experience with Crunch, praises well-kept equipment, enjoyable classes, and good staff; mentions a 12-month contract with limited flexibility for cancellation.
- Recommends Crunch for beginners, highlights cleanliness, variety of equipment, and affordable pricing; notes potential negatives, such as limited hours and varying hours by location.
- Shares positive experience, mentions the addition of a squat rack; praises Crunch for its affordability and availability of equipment.
- Describes a negative experience, feeling judged, and limited equipment; compares the atmosphere to Planet Fitness, suggesting Crunch caters more to less frequent gym-goers.
- Positive experience with friendly staff, easy access to classes, and a well-equipped weight area; highlights the gym's atmosphere and variety of exercise options.
- Confirms that Crunch in the building is a full-featured gym, not just a corporate fitness center.
- Describes Crunch as cheap and meeting most needs; highlights the addition of a squat rack but mentions limitations. (source)
Who is Planet Fitness For?
Planet Fitness is great for more casual and beginner lifters looking for a non-intimidating environment. Here's a closer look at who PF may be best for.
- Beginners and Novices: Planet Fitness prides itself on being a "Judgment-Free Zone," creating an environment specifically tailored to welcome individuals who are new to fitness or might feel intimidated in traditional gym settings.
- Budget-Conscious Individuals: With a basic membership typically priced around $10 per month, Planet Fitness offers an affordable entry point to the fitness world. This makes it accessible to those on a tight budget who are looking for an economical yet effective gym option.
- Casual Gym-Goers: If your fitness routine leans towards simplicity and you prefer a more relaxed atmosphere, Planet Fitness provides the basics without overwhelming you with an extensive array of workout options.
- Those Seeking a Relaxed Environment: Planet Fitness prioritizes creating a non-intimidating and supportive atmosphere. If you're looking for a laid-back gym where you can comfortably start your fitness journey, Planet Fitness is a suitable choice.
To learn more about PF, check out our article comparing LA Fitness vs Planet Fitness!
Who is Crunch For?
If you're a more advanced lifter or someone looking for more weight lifting equipment and amenities, Crunch Fitness may be the better choice for you.
- Fitness Enthusiasts: Crunch Fitness caters to individuals who thrive in an energetic and motivating atmosphere. If you are enthusiastic about fitness, diverse workout options, and a dynamic community, Crunch provides an environment that aligns with your passion.
- Variety Seekers: With diverse workout options, including traditional gym equipment and innovative classes like High-Intensity Interval Training (HIIT) and dance-based workouts, Crunch is perfect for those who appreciate variety and intensity in their exercise routine.
- Individuals Looking for Premium Amenities: The tiered club structure of Crunch, including franchise, signature, and select clubs, provides options for those seeking additional amenities such as pools, basketball courts, towel services, and a broader assortment of classes.
- People Seeking a Community Vibe: Crunch Fitness is known for fostering a dynamic fitness community. If you enjoy a sense of camaraderie, encouragement, and social interaction during your workouts, Crunch is designed to provide a community-driven experience.
Planet Fitness vs Crunch: Comparing Side By Side
We just covered a ton of information about each gym. Here's a look at them side by side to help you figure out which is best for you.
|
Feature |
Crunch Fitness |
Planet Fitness |
|
Founding Year |
1989 |
1992 |
|
Philosophy |
No judgment zone |
Judgment-free zone |
|
Atmosphere |
Energetic and motivating |
Non-intimidating and supportive |
|
Target Audience |
Fitness enthusiasts |
Beginners |
|
Membership Pricing |
Basic membership |
Basic membership |
|
Equipment Variety |
Diverse equipment, including innovative classes |
Focus on basic cardio & strength equipment |
|
Classes and Workouts |
High-Intensity Interval Training (HIIT), dance, etc. |
Basic group fitness classes |
|
Amenities |
Tiered club structure; Pools, basketball courts |
Standard amenities with consistency across locations |
|
Virtual Tours |
Virtual tours available on the official website & YouTube |
Virtual tours provided through the website & YouTube |
|
Real Customer Reviews |
Positive reviews on equipment variety and atmosphere |
Varied opinions with emphasis on beginner-friendly environment |
Our verdict: Both Crunch Fitness and Planet Fitness have distinct features catering to diverse preferences and fitness goals. Crunch stands out for its energetic atmosphere, diverse offerings, and tiered club structure, appealing to fitness enthusiasts. On the other hand, Planet Fitness excels in creating a non-intimidating space for beginners, focusing on simplicity and affordability. And when it comes down to it, both offer affordable gym memberships. The choice between them ultimately depends on individual preferences, fitness levels, and desired gym experiences.
FAQs
Do you have any lingering questions regarding Planet Fitness vs Crunch Fitness? Let's answer them here!
Can You Go to Any Planet Fitness With a $10 Membership?
The $10 membership only allows your home location. Planet Fitness members with a standard membership can visit any Planet Fitness location as long as it is within their membership's designated home club area. The home club is typically where the membership was initially purchased or registered.
Is Planet Fitness a Good Gym?
Planet Fitness is a good gym for beginners and those seeking an affordable, judgment-free workout environment. With a focus on simplicity, accessibility, and inclusivity, Planet Fitness promotes all gym goers feeling comfortable there. The gym provides a comfortable entry point for individuals new to fitness or those who may feel apprehensive in traditional gym settings.
Why is Crunch Fitness so Popular?
Crunch Fitness's popularity can be attributed to several factors:
- Diverse Range of Classes: Crunch offers a wide array of workout options, including traditional gym equipment and innovative classes like High-Intensity Interval Training (HIIT) and dance-based workouts.
- Motivating Atmosphere: The gym is known for its energetic and motivating atmosphere, creating a dynamic fitness community.
- Varied Membership Options: Crunch provides a range of membership options to cater to different preferences and budgets, contributing to its broad appeal.
Do Planet Fitness and Crunch offer personal training services?
Planet Fitness does provide personal trainers and small group training sessions, but personal training sessions may not be as comprehensive compared to other gyms. It's worth noting that PF's membership includes free fitness training. Crunch Fitness offers a more comprehensive training package with highly certified trainers that can provide workout programs and nutrition guidance.
Does Crunch Fitness Have Red Light Therapy?
While amenities may vary by location, some Crunch Fitness locations do offer red light therapy as part of their services. It's advisable to check with the specific Crunch Fitness location you are interested in to confirm the availability of red light therapy and other amenities.
Crunch photos courtesy of Crunch Instagram and Website
Crunch Fitness vs Planet Fitness: Final Verdict
The choice between Crunch Fitness and Planet Fitness boils down to your individual preferences and fitness objectives. The good news is both have affordable membership options. If you're searching for a gym that exudes energy and offers a diverse workout environment, Crunch Fitness might be your go-to option.
The motivating classes, ranging from traditional workouts to innovative sessions like HIIT and dance-based exercises, cater to those who thrive on variety. On the other hand, if you're a beginner or someone on a budget looking for a welcoming and non-intimidating atmosphere, Planet Fitness could be the perfect fit.
With its "Judgment-Free Zone" philosophy, Planet Fitness prioritizes simplicity and accessibility. The gym's straightforward cardio and strength equipment and basic fitness classes create a comfortable space for those who prefer a straightforward workout routine.
Ultimately, the final verdict on the best gym memberships hinges on what resonates with you – the dynamic and varied experience of Crunch Fitness or the straightforward, budget-friendly, and functional training spaces that come with Planet Fitness. Consider your fitness goals, preferred workout environment, and the community that inspires you to choose the gym that best suits your needs.
Readers: Are You Team Crunch or Team PF? (Leave us a comment below!)
If you're interested in exploring more gyms before making a decision, be sure to check out our article: Anytime Fitness vs Planet Fitness: Which Is The Better Gym For You? And, if you're willing to pay more for top-of-the-line amenities, head to our Life Time Fitness Review to learn more about the high-end gym.
Andrew Lenau
Author