Written by Andrew Lenau | ISSA CPT & Sports Nutritionist
Fact checked by Kirsten Yovino, CPT Brookbush Institute
FACT CHECKED
With numerous gym options to choose from, it can be challenging to decide which one best fits your specific needs and aspirations. Take LA Fitness and Planet Fitness, for example, which are two of the most prominent and frequently considered gym chains in the fitness industry.
These fitness centers have carved out their unique niches within the fitness landscape, offering distinct experiences, amenities, and membership options that cater to a broad spectrum of potential gym-goers. In this comprehensive comparison, we will explore what sets each of these gyms apart.
By delving deep into their characteristics, we'll provide you with a clear understanding of what you can expect from each gym and assist you in finding the one that best aligns with your goals.
Table of Contents:
- What Is Planet Fitness?
- What Is LA Fitness?
- La Fitness vs Planet Fitness: Which Is Better For You?
- Planet Fitness vs LA Fitness: Cost Comparison, Virtual Tours, Real Reddit Reviews
- Comparing LA & Planet Fitness Side By Side
- FAQs
What is Planet Fitness?
Planet Fitness, often called the "Judgment-Free Zone," is a distinct beacon in the fitness industry. This gym chain has made a name by prioritizing inclusivity and affordability, offering a welcoming space for individuals of all fitness levels. In doing so, the gym separates itself from more expensive options along with similarly priced competitors, like Anytime Fitness.
The "Judgment-Free Zone" is not merely a marketing slogan; it's a way of life within Planet Fitness. Upon entering any of their gyms, you immediately feel the difference in the atmosphere.
It's designed to be non-intimidating and supportive, making it particularly appealing to beginners or anyone who may have felt uncomfortable in traditional gym settings. Beyond just branding, the distinctive purple and yellow color scheme serves as a visual embodiment of the gym's mission to create an inclusive and judgment-free environment.
Planet Fitness understands that intimidation can be a significant deterrent for many people considering joining a gym. To counter this, they've crafted an atmosphere where everyone feels comfortable and accepted, regardless of their fitness experience.
Planet Fitness's cost-effective membership options further bolster its appeal, making it accessible to a broad spectrum of individuals, even those on a tight budget. Whether starting your fitness journey or simply seeking a budget-friendly, supportive fitness community, Planet Fitness embodies the spirit of fitness for all.
Planet Fitness Pros:
- Affordable Membership: Planet Fitness is known for its affordable membership options, making it a budget-friendly choice for those looking to fit without breaking the bank.
- Judgment-Free Zone: The gym has a strict policy against gym intimidation, fostering a comfortable atmosphere for beginners and those who might feel self-conscious about their fitness level.
- 24/7 Access: Many Planet Fitness locations are open 24/7, providing members with flexibility in their workout schedules.
Planet Fitness Cons:
- Basic Equipment: Planet Fitness is often criticized for its limited variety of gym equipment, which might not cater to more experienced or specialized workout routines.
- Lack of Free Weights: Some locations lack free weights, which could be a drawback for those looking to build strength through traditional weightlifting.
To see how PF stacks up to a few other gyms, check out our articles comparing Anytime Fitness vs Planet Fitness and Crunch vs Planet Fitness.
What is LA Fitness?
Unlike Planet Fitness, LA Fitness is a full-service fitness center tailored to individuals seeking an all-encompassing and versatile gym experience. This fitness chain has gained a reputation for providing an extensive range of amenities and services, rendering it a top choice among fitness enthusiasts pursuing a premium fitness journey. It even made our list of runner-ups in our round-up of the Best Gyms in Chicago.
With its commitment to offering a comprehensive fitness environment, LA Fitness is a go-to destination for those who desire a holistic approach to health and well-being. While Planet Fitness prides itself on simplicity and affordability, LA Fitness differentiates itself by offering various exercise options.
It encompasses many amenities, including a rich selection of workout equipment, group fitness classes, swimming pools, sports courts, locker rooms, and more. For individuals who relish an extensive and versatile workout regimen, LA Fitness provides a conducive environment to achieve their fitness objectives.
Whether you're aspiring to build strength, enhance cardiovascular health, or explore various fitness modalities, LA Fitness caters to the diverse needs of fitness enthusiasts willing to invest in a premium fitness experience.
LA Fitness Pros:
- Diverse Equipment: LA Fitness boasts an extensive array of workout and strength training equipment, including free weights, machines, and cardio machines, suitable for various workout styles.
- Group Fitness Classes: LA Fitness offers a wide selection of classes catering to different preferences and fitness goals.
- Swimming Pools and Sports Courts: Many LA Fitness locations feature swimming pools and sports courts, providing opportunities for additional recreational activities.
LA Fitness Cons:
- Higher Membership Costs: LA Fitness membership fees tend to be higher than Planet Fitness's, potentially deterring budget-conscious individuals.
- Potentially Crowded: Due to its popularity, LA Fitness locations can become crowded during peak hours, leading to longer wait times for equipment.
LA Fitness vs. Planet Fitness: Which is Better?
Now that we understand what both Planet Fitness and LA Fitness offer, let's delve into a detailed comparison to help you make an informed choice based on your preferences and fitness goals.
1) Gym Fees:
LA Fitness typically offers multiple membership plans with varying costs. The monthly fees can range from $30 to $60 or more, depending on your local gym and the type of membership you choose. Additionally, LA Fitness often requires an initiation fee and an annual fee.
Planet Fitness is renowned for its affordability. The standard multi-club membership usually costs around $10 per month, while the Black Card membership, which includes additional perks like guest privileges and tanning, is typically priced around $22 per month. Planet Fitness also charges an annual fee, typically lower than LA Fitness's.
Verdict: If budget-friendliness is your top priority, Planet Fitness is the clear winner in this category. However, if you want to invest more in a premium fitness experience, LA Fitness might be your preferred choice.
Another thing to consider, particularly you don't love the idea of contracts or paying a monthly gym fee, is whether setting up a home gym is a good option for you. Learn more about the expenses associated with a home gym in our article: Is It Cheaper To Have A Home Gym Or Gym Membership?
2) Contract Length:
LA Fitness often requires members to commit to a 12-month contract. While shorter-term options might be available, they often come at a higher monthly cost.
Planet Fitness usually offers a no-contract membership, allowing members to cancel without additional fees.
Verdict: If flexibility and the option to cancel at any time are important to you, Planet Fitness takes the lead in this category. With its contract requirement, LA Fitness is more suitable for individuals confident in their long-term commitment to fitness.
3) Gym Equipment:
LA Fitness provides various workout equipment, including free weights, resistance machines, cardio equipment, and more. This variety makes it an excellent choice for those with specific fitness goals or who want to diversify their workouts.
While equipped with primary exercise machines, Planet Fitness tends to have a more limited selection, particularly regarding free weights. This might be restrictive for those seeking advanced strength training.
Verdict: If you're a serious fitness enthusiast looking for a gym with diverse equipment, LA Fitness is the better choice. Planet Fitness, on the other hand, caters more to beginners and those who prefer a more straightforward workout routine.
4) Atmosphere:
LA Fitness locations vary but are generally seen as more traditional fitness centers. The atmosphere varies from a relaxed and friendly environment to a more intense and focused one, depending on the location and time of day.
Planet Fitness prides itself on creating a Judgment-Free Zone. This gym is specifically designed to be welcoming and non-intimidating. It's a place where people of all fitness levels should feel comfortable working out.
Verdict: If you're looking for a gym with a welcoming and judgment-free atmosphere, Planet Fitness is the clear winner. LA Fitness is better suited for those comfortable in a more traditional gym setting.
5) Gym Policies:
LA Fitness may have stricter policies regarding dress code and guest access. Some locations may be more stringent in enforcing these policies than others.
Planet Fitness is known for its lenient policies and the "no gym intimidation" philosophy. They have a more relaxed approach to rules and regulations.
Verdict: If you prefer a gym with a more relaxed approach to policies, Planet Fitness aligns with this preference. On the other hand, LA Fitness may be a better fit if you appreciate a structured environment.
6) Group fitness classes:
LA Fitness offers various group fitness classes, including yoga, Zumba, cycling, and more. These classes are typically included in your membership.
Planet Fitness provides some small group training sessions, but their selection is generally more limited than LA Fitness.
Verdict: If you enjoy participating in various group fitness classes, LA Fitness is your better choice. While offering some classes, Planet Fitness might not have as extensive a selection.
7) Personal training services:
LA Fitness offers personal training sessions with certified trainers for an additional fee. These sessions can be tailored to your specific fitness goals.
There is no dedicated personal training program at Planet Fitness. If you're seeking a personal trainer for training guidance, LA Fitness would be the most suitable choice.
Verdict: If you're looking for one-on-one guidance and personal training, LA Fitness is the clear winner in this category. Planet Fitness doesn't offer this service.
8) Amenities:
LA Fitness provides a range of additional amenities, including swimming pools, sports courts, saunas, and racquetball courts at many locations. These amenities can add to the overall fitness experience.
Planet Fitness offers fewer additional amenities. However, the Black Card membership provides some extras, such as access to tanning beds, massage chairs, and guest privileges.
Verdict: If you're looking for a gym with a broader range of amenities, particularly swimming pools and basketball courts, LA Fitness is the better choice. Planet Fitness's Black Card membership offers additional perks, but they are limited compared to LA Fitness.
9) Locations:
LA Fitness has a substantial presence in the United States, with numerous locations in various states. Finding an LA Fitness in most metropolitan areas is relatively easy. Plus, with your membership, you can then access any LA Fitness location nationwide.
Planet Fitness has a vast network of gyms throughout the United States, making it highly accessible to many people. The "Judgment-Free Zone" can be found in numerous cities and towns.
Verdict: Both LA Fitness and Planet Fitness have extensive networks of locations. The availability of either gym largely depends on your specific location. It's advisable to check the availability of gyms in your area before deciding.
10) Open Times:
LA Fitness locations typically have extensive operating hours, often opening early in the morning and closing late at night. Some even operate 24/7.
Many Planet Fitness locations are also open 24/7, allowing members to work out at any time that suits their schedule.
Verdict: LA Fitness and Planet Fitness offer extended hours, making it convenient for early birds and night owls to fit their workouts into their schedules.
LA vs Planet Fitness: Virtual Tours
If you're curious to explore what LA Fitness and Planet Fitness offer before deciding, virtual tours can be an excellent way to get a sneak peek into these gym environments. Let's take a virtual stroll through both fitness chains to give you a better idea of what they are like:
LA Fitness Virtual Tour:
To take a virtual tour of LA Fitness, visit their official website or YouTube channel, where they often share video tours of their facilities. These tours will give you an overview of their extensive workout areas, equipment, swimming pools, group fitness studios, and other amenities.
Additionally, LA Fitness might provide 360-degree virtual tours on its website, allowing you to explore different gym sections and get a feel for the atmosphere. Here's a look inside an LA Fitness gym.
Planet Fitness Virtual Tour:
Planet Fitness offers virtual tours through its official website and social media channels. These tours showcase their gym spaces, unique "Judgment-Free Zone" atmosphere, cardio equipment, and strength training areas, and additional amenities like tanning beds and massage chairs.
Be sure to visit the Planet Fitness website and YouTube channel for an immersive look at what you can expect when you enter one of their welcoming gyms.
La Fitness vs Planet Fitness: Real Reddit Reviews
When comparing La Fitness vs Planet Fitness, the best advice you can get is from those who have already gone to them. Actual gym goer reviews provide you with insights into the pros, cons, and overall vibes.
Let's check out what each are like.
1) LA Fitness Reddit Reviews:
As soon as you start reviewing Reddit reviews, an alarming sticking point with LA Fitness is their membership costs.
Redditor Opinion #1: Be Wary Of LA Fitness Pricing
In a Reddit forum titled: "Can anyone explain simply LA fitness’s pricing?" numerous Redditors warned against LA Fitness membership pricing.
One user stated: "Run… run fast and run far. LA fitness is notorious for making their membership levels and cancelling harder than 3D chess." (source)
Another Redditor (MCap1028) stated: "It’s all a sales pitch. I worked at LA. They show these ridiculous prices in hopes that you take it. I don’t know if they still have it but you can negotiate to no down payment and like $40 a month. May be a on location basis but I’d give it a try." (source)
Another user (jitsufitchick) gave this advice:
Redditor Opinion #2: LA Fitness Has Great Equipment Variety
In a separate forum titled: "Is LA Fitness Worth The Price?" Redditors were a bit more positive about the gym, although you'll still find plenty warning about LA Fitness' pricing.
One Redditor (strawberryfields01) stated: "If you go there just for the treadmills, no. In all seriousness, tell us how you like to work out so we can better judge. If you’re a machine buff then yes. If you enjoy pools and saunas, then also yes. If you like classes, then yes. If you just like to do cardio, then most likely no as you can run outside and join your local YMCA or what not for probably less." (source)
Another user (Willisdo) states: "I believe LA Fitness is worth it if you are going to be using all of their equipment, amenities and/or taking their classes. Tip: If you google AAA LA Fitness discount you’ll be able to get the membership for $0 initiation and $30 a month. They don’t require you to login to a AAA membership account." (source)
2) Planet Fitness Reddit Reviews:
In general, gym goers seem to better things to say about Planet Fitness compared to La Fitness, but cons do still exist. In addition, the Planet Fitness target market seems to be those newer to lifting.
Redditor Opinion #1: PF Is Great For Most Gym Goers But Stereotypes Heavy Lifters
In a Reddit forum titled "Unpopular Gym Opinion: Planet Fitness Is A Great Gym" the original poster (International_Cap245) states:
"The only people who have no business working out at pf are powerlifters. For everyone else it’s a great option. Totally affordable, tons of equipment, and a great environment. We really do advocate for the judgement free zone. That goes for the 400 lb guys trying to lose some weight, and the beefy guys trying to add an inch to their biceps. We get both, and everyone in between. I manage the planet fitness in my area, so I know for a fact there is no discrimination against big guys. I work out there everyday and I’m 6’4 / 230 lbs. Hell, my boss is literally an ifbb pro, and he works out at planet fitness." (source)
Another Redditor (1000FacesCosplay) chimed in, critiquing PF for stereotyping bodybuilders. "I like PF aside from one aspect: their hypocrisy with their slogan. 'No judgement' and 'judgment free zone', while labeling people who wear a certain type of shirt and carry around a gallon jug of water 'lunks'. Doesn't sound judgment free to me. If you want to ban serious lifters and bodybuilders and powerlifters, fine, do it. But don't claim to be a judgment free zone while clearly passing judgment as part of your company decor and policy." (source)
Redditor Opinion #2: Not Great Equipment Variety, But Great For Beginners
One Redditor (DynoMenace) provides a comprehensive overview for gym goers considering PF:
A separate Redditor (hypno_notic) explains:
"It’s great for those just starting out, casual and intermediate. If you go 3 times a week and really starting to fill out as a guy you are most likely going to end up lifting more or need different machines than PF has. Within a year even starting over after 10+ years away I was starting to outgrow the gym. I like it because it’s cheap, and super close to home and work for me in a smaller city." (source)
Who is LA Fitness For?
LA Fitness is the perfect fit for a specific group of fitness enthusiasts ready to invest in a comprehensive gym experience. If you're serious about achieving your fitness goals and committing to your health, LA Fitness offers many advantages that align with your aspirations.
- Dedicated Fitness Enthusiasts: LA Fitness caters to individuals deeply committed to their fitness journeys. Suppose you enjoy spending considerable time at the gym, exploring various exercises, and pushing your boundaries. In that case, LA Fitness offers diverse equipment and services to keep you engaged and motivated.
- Variety Seekers: LA Fitness is well-suited for those who value variety in their workouts. With a wide array of exercise machines, free weights, and specialized equipment, you'll be free to experiment with different training styles and techniques, allowing you to challenge and improve yourself continually.
- Group Fitness Aficionados: If you appreciate the camaraderie and motivation of group fitness classes, LA Fitness provides a robust schedule of classes, from yoga and Zumba to spinning and HIIT. These group workouts are ideal for individuals who thrive in a structured class setting.
- Traditional Gym Environment Enthusiasts: LA Fitness offers a more conventional gym atmosphere, which might be precisely what you're looking for. This is the place for you if you feel at ease in a classic gym setting with various fitness zones, personal trainers, and a broader gym community.
Who is Planet Fitness For?
Planet Fitness is tailored for a distinct group of individuals who might have different priorities and preferences when it comes to fitness:
- Beginners and Novices: Planet Fitness is an excellent choice for individuals who are new to fitness. The gym's "Judgment-Free Zone" philosophy ensures a welcoming and non-intimidating environment for those taking initial steps into the fitness world.
- Budget-Conscious Individuals: If you're looking for an affordable gym option that won't break the bank, Planet Fitness's cost-effective membership plans are well-suited to individuals on a budget.
- Simplicity Seekers: Planet Fitness is ideal for those who prefer a straightforward and uncomplicated workout routine. The gym may not have an extensive selection of equipment or additional amenities, but it offers the basics for a productive workout.
- Those Looking For Judgment-Free Atmosphere: The gym's core mission is to provide a judgment-free, relaxed environment where all individuals, regardless of their fitness level, feel at ease and welcome. If you value this type of atmosphere and want to work out without the fear of judgment, Planet Fitness is an excellent choice.
La Fitness vs Planet Fitness: Comparing Side By Side
Let's take a look at these two gyms side by side to help you find your perfect gym match.
|
Aspect |
LA Fitness |
Planet Fitness |
|
Membership Cost |
Typically higher |
Affordable options |
|
Contract Length |
Often requires 12-month commitment |
No-contract memberships |
|
Gym Equipment |
Diverse range |
Basic equipment |
|
Atmosphere |
Varied |
Judgment-Free Zone |
|
Group Classes |
Wide selection |
Limited selection |
|
Personal Training |
Offers personal training sessions for extra fee |
No dedicated personal training program |
|
Amenities |
Extensive amenities, including pools and sports courts |
Fewer amenities |
|
Policies |
Stricter dress code and guest access |
Relaxed policies |
|
Locations |
Numerous locations nationwide |
Vast network of gyms throughout the US |
|
Open Times |
Extensive operating hours, some locations open 24/7 |
Many locations open 24/7 for flexible workout times |
FAQs
Let's answer some frequently asked questions regarding La Fitness vs Planet Fitness.
Which Gym is Best for Beginners?
Planet Fitness often emerges as the preferred choice for individuals taking their first steps into the fitness world. The absence of judgmental attitudes or unwarranted pressure is especially reassuring for beginners, helping to build confidence as you establish a regular workout routine. Planet Fitness's straightforward approach to fitness and the absence of complex training equipment make it a fantastic place to learn the basics and build a strong fitness foundation.
Is a Gym Membership Worth It?
If you're genuinely dedicated to incorporating the gym into your routine and making the most of its offerings, membership can be a valuable investment in your health and overall well-being. Gyms provide a structured and well-equipped environment for exercise, professional guidance, group classes, and access to various training tools. Consider your commitment and how often you foresee yourself using the gym to determine the true worth of the membership.
Can Joining a Gym Help Me Lose Weight?
Joining a gym can be a valuable component of a weight loss strategy, as it grants you access to a diverse array of exercise equipment, ranging from cardio machines to strength-training apparatus. But remember, to achieve effective and sustainable weight loss, regular exercise needs to be paired with a balanced and nutritious diet, proper hydration, adequate rest, and other healthy lifestyle habits.
Does Planet Fitness have free weights?
Some Planet Fitness locations offer limited free weights, typically in dumbbells. However, the availability of free weights can vary from one location to another. For individuals specifically interested in free weight training, it's advisable to inquire with your local Planet Fitness gym to ascertain the extent of their free weight offerings.
LA Fitness images courtesy of LA Fitness' Instagram
La Fitness vs Planet Fitness: Final Verdict
The ultimate decision between LA Fitness and Planet Fitness boils down to your preferences and fitness goals. LA Fitness excels in providing a premium fitness experience with a wide array of equipment, group fitness classes, and additional amenities.
However, it has a higher price tag and may be more suitable for serious fitness enthusiasts. On the other hand, Planet Fitness offers affordability, a welcoming atmosphere, and 24/7 access, making it an excellent choice for beginners and those who prefer a straightforward, no-frills approach to fitness.
Our Verdict: If you're looking for convenience, a cheap gym membership, and a welcoming environment for beginners, Planet Fitness is a great choice. Powerlifters or gym goers looking for more amenities and a comprehensive fitness experience may be better suited to LA Fitness.
Interested in more gym comparisons? Check out our articles comparing Crunch vs Planet Fitness and Anytime Fitness vs Planet Fitness!
Planet Fitness images courtesy of Planet Fitness Instagram
Andrew Lenau
Author